Columbus Crew: 46%
New York City FC: 54%
Columbus Crew: 13
New York City FC: 16
Columbus Crew: 6
New York City FC: 6
Columbus Crew: 4
New York City FC: 8
Columbus Crew: 0
New York City FC: 1
Columbus Crew: 9
New York City FC: 14
Columbus Crew: 1
New York City FC: 2
Columbus Crew: 0
New York City FC: 1
Columbus Crew: 442
New York City FC: 515
Columbus Crew: -1
New York City FC: -1
Columbus Crew: 364 (82%)
New York City FC: 437 (85%)