| MLS Cup - Round 1
| MLS Cup - Round 1
| MLS Cup - Round 1
| Regular Season - 49
| Regular Season - 48
| Regular Season - 46
| Regular Season - 45
| Regular Season - 45
| Regular Season - 42
| Regular Season - 41
| Regular Season - 41
| Regular Season - 40
| Regular Season - 39
| Regular Season - 38
| Regular Season - 36
Columbus Crew
